| Emanuel S. Goldsmith's book was a pioneering
achievement in modern Jewish scholarship. It was the first history
of the Yiddishist movement. In one master stroke, it enabled the
bold, open-minded reader to overcome the myriad prejudices and misconceptions
that continue to misguide popular notions about Yiddish and the
Yiddish language movement.
Now the historians of events, and (especially) the historians of
ideas are supposed to maintain a studious "distance" from
their material. That Professor Goldsmith did in the two incarnations
of this splendid book. Still, the highly charged nature of the relevant
controversies, and the ongoing heated debate about them, left readers
wondering: And what does Professor Goldsmith say? In addition to
his professorial persona at Queens College, he is after all an eminent
Reconstructionist rabbi and a beloved writer and lecturer on Jewish
thought.
David Katz
Oxford University.
|